This book begins with a strikingly familiar scene, perhaps too close to home: George, a man in his late fifties awakes and goes through his morning routine. He stares into his bathroom mirror and sees in it little reminders of the various stages of his life, hidden within its current self. “What it sees there isn’t so much a face as the expression of a predicament.” He is a single man because he is the survivor of a long term relationship with a man named Jim.
His singularity has multiple sources.
First and foremost, he is alone because few people ever acknowledged
their relationship, despite its obvious existence. He is alone because he can no longer
self-define as half of a couple, though he has not a clue how to define his
current state. And, he is alone because
is a gay man living an existence a decade before the sexual revolution.
The book is written by Christopher Isherwood (1904 – 1986) who is best
known for Berlin Stories, the source of the movie Cabaret. I’ve recently begun reading his other works,
and I am touched by the staying power of his observations. Like Berlin Stories, A Single Man, has also been
turned into a movie. It scored a well-deserved Oscar nomination for Colin
Firth. I waited until I finished the
book, before watching the movie last night.
Although the Director has taken some artistic license with the script,
he has not harmed the impact of Isherwood’s story. In fact, I will argue that some of the chapters
perhaps worked even better on film – the flashbacks telling of George’s relationship
with Jim in particular. The role of his
close friend Charley was somewhat enhanced to take advantage of the stature of
actress Julianne Moore, but fortunately no attempt was made to assign them a
relationship beyond what was in the book. And the role of Kenny, a college
student, was somewhat downgraded, unfortunate because actor Nicholas Hoult
clearly could have handled the character’s complexity.
As always, my recommendation would be read the book, but knowing that
most people will not, let me say the movie is also a recommended – both however,
would be better.
No comments:
Post a Comment